When do the Sea Angling Diary Project surveys take place?

The Sea Angling Diary project has been running since 2016. In 2016 and 2017 it was called Sea Angling 2016 and Sea Angling 2017 respectively. During 2017 it was renamed Sea Angling Diary project. It will run continue to run each year until contracted otherwise.

How do we work with the angling community?

Although there is no official steering group for this survey, input is regularly received via meetings with angling and other stakeholders. We work with a wider range of angling stakeholders who support the project including: Angling Trust Welsh Federation of Sea Anglers / Angling Cymru Angling Trades Association Association of Inshore Fisheries and Conservation Authorities Institute of Fisheries Management National Mullet Club Bass Anglers’ Sportfishing Society BritishSeaFishing.co.uk Fishing Megastore [gallery columns="5" link="none" size="fusion-200" ids="5344,5337,5343,5339,5338,5340,5342,5341"]

What is the relationship between the Sea Angling Diary and Catchwise?

Catchwise and the Sea Angling Diary are ran both by Substance. Catchwise is a year project that runs from July 2023 to July 2024 for shore anglers, and October 2023 to October 2024 for charter boats. Catchwise was set up to understand the bias in the Sea Angling Diary Project, and determine the confidence in the data that is produced by the Sea Angling Diary. The outputs for the two projects will be compared in a robust analysis and modelling exercise conducted by Cefas. The results of Catchwise will inform how the Sea Angling Diary project data is used in the future. To find out more about Catchwise, click here.

What survey methods are used?

The Sea Angling Diary Project has two components: 1. A nationwide face-to-face survey to estimate sea angling participation and effort, using questions added to the Watersports Participation Survey each year; 2. A ‘diary panel’ survey involving the completion of monthly diaries, over a year, in a mobile app and online tool by those who agree to take part, collecting information about: Fishing sessions; Methods, platforms, duration and whether or not they are targeting a species; Catches including kept and released fish (including lengths); Expenditure; Social impacts. Estimates of recreational sea angling catches and trip expenditure from the diary panel are used to derive estimates for the whole population of sea anglers, based on estimates of the total nationwide numbers of sea anglers from the Watersports Participation Survey. The different surveys will be broken down by region, demographic characteristics and frequency of angling to correct for any biases caused by the diary panel not being fully representative of the total population of sea anglers. There are many potential ways of collecting information on recreational sea angling, all of which have different strengths. This design has been selected to give a reasonable level of precision and minimise bias using experience from previous studies, and used routinely by other scientists in Europe, USA, Australia and New Zealand. Overall, this design was thought to provide the best value for money and give reasonable estimates.

What are the potential negative effects of angling surveys?

As stated above, the Government would not wish to impose unnecessary regulatory burdens on sea anglers. Angling surveys and other surveys may indicate that there are species in particular areas where recreational activity could be considered to be having a significant additional impact, which is the case for sea bass and could also be true for some other species. If this is the case, UK governments would initially prefer to develop voluntary measures which will reduce the recreational impact on the stock, but not affect the enjoyment of the sport. This may take the form of catch-and-release after a certain number of fish have been retained or voluntarily avoiding areas where large quantities of small fish are being caught. This may be seen as a negative effect of surveys, but in reality the absence of such data could lead to even more precautionary measures and more restrictive controls due to a greater uncertainty about the total impacts of fishing. Of course, angling surveys may demonstrate that recreational activity is having a negligible effect on stocks, and there is no need to seek additional voluntary or regulatory measures for those stocks. However, we cannot assume that will be the case, which is why it is important to have data collected as accurately as possible. Well-informed decisions are important for the benefit of all stakeholders.

What happens if anglers do not want to participate in the collection of data?

Quite simply, the more people willing to take part, the better the quality of the information produced. And the more accurate the data, the better represented sea angling will be. It is a popular misconception that the absence of data would result in sea angling being ignored when fishery managers are considering how best to conserve fish stocks. In contrast, if there is evidence that a fish stock is in need of stronger conservation measures, management decisions may have to be based on a worst-case view where there are large uncertainties in knowledge of the fish stocks and what is being caught. If accurate information is available about recreational angling, those decisions will be based on what is actually the case. For this reason, it is in everyone’s interests to have accurate, verifiable data on sea angling so that it has a clearer picture of the state of stocks and sea angling’s value to the economy. This will facilitate working with sea angling bodies to develop more effective voluntary or regulatory conservation measures if needed, and to contribute more effectively to national and international policy development. In the longer term this can only be to the benefit of sea angling, particularly where there is a need to restore important recreational angling stocks to healthier and more productive levels.

Why is the focus on recreational sea angling when it is clear that commercial fishing has a much larger impact?

Commercial fisheries already have a heavy burden of catch reporting through log-books, and there are large programmes of data collection by national fishery laboratories to establish the size and age compositions of catches, and quantities discarded. These are key inputs to scientific assessments of most fish stocks. For important recreational stocks, estimates of recreational catches would improve the accuracy of assessments of the state of the stocks. This would help to achieve conservation goals and eventually improve the availability of fish to sea anglers.

Should sea anglers be concerned that these data will lead to restrictions?

Some anglers believe that the purpose of angling surveys is ultimately to control sea angling. This is not the case, as the government would not wish to impose unnecessary regulatory burdens where they are not needed. However, where there is strong evidence that a fish stock is being overfished and badly depleted due to the combined effect of commercial and recreational fishing, all people involved in taking fish of this species from the sea should bear a responsibility to help conserve and restore the stock. Without good data on what is being caught by all types of fishing, it becomes very difficult to develop the most effective packages of measures to achieve this and to predict and monitor their outcome. Sea angling surveys could highlight circumstances where anglers should play an important role along with commercial fishermen in this process of restoring vulnerable or overexploited stocks, for example bass. In this case governments would seek to work with the angling sector to agree voluntary measures or to contribute as effectively as possible to development of international and domestic regulatory measures where there is a clear need for them.

What impact will it have on the development of sea angling?

If sea angling is to be strongly represented in marine fishery management, there is a need for up-to-date evidence to stand alongside data on other marine activities. It is vital that information on sea angling is as accurate as possible – in terms of how often people go fishing, what is caught, what is released and what is contributed to the economy. The data from 2016-19 are freely available in the published reports. All data from the programme will be freely available, so can be used by angling organisations to develop policies on important issues facing sea angling. Consultation on new fisheries legislation has suggested a new and improved role for recreational sea angling within wider marine fisheries management. This emphasises the need for better data on sea angling to properly inform that management.

Who Supports the Project?

The research is supported by a wide range of angling, fishery and marine organisations: Angling Trust Angling Cymru / Welsh Federation of Sea Anglers Angling Trades Association Association of Inshore Fisheries and Conservation Authorities Institute of Fisheries Management National Mullet Club Bass Anglers’ Sportfishing Society BritishSeaFishing.co.uk Fishing Megastore Fishing Megastore have supported the project since 2016 and provide tackle vouchers as incentives for participation, which are distributed via prize draws for participants.